Read the appraisal before making a decision

Open a Pokémon’s details, open its menu and choose Appraise. The three bars describe its individual Attack, Defense and HP potential. These individual values are usually called IVs. Each runs from zero to fifteen; a Pokémon with all three at fifteen is commonly called a hundo. Stars summarize that spread, rather than rating every possible use of the Pokémon.

Start by comparing duplicates of the same species and form. A high appraisal on one species does not mean it will outperform every lower-appraisal species. Different Pokémon have different underlying stats, types and available attacks. Think of appraisal as one piece of a decision that also includes your available resources and the battle you want to enter.

Understand why CP is different

Combat Power is a summary of a Pokémon’s current battle stats. Its power-up level and individual values contribute to that number. It is useful for checking entry restrictions and comparing similar Pokémon, but it does not directly measure how effective a particular attack will be against an opponent. A larger number cannot cancel a poor type matchup.

For example, suppose you have two copies of a useful raid attacker. One already has enough CP to help your team; the other has a better appraisal but needs substantial investment. The first can be the better choice for tonight’s raid. Keep the promising second copy for a future project instead of assuming you must rebuild immediately.

Match the Pokémon to its job

For raids, ask whether the species has an effective attacking type and a suitable moveset before comparing small IV differences. For a CP-limited league, ask whether its final form can stay within the cap. Some competitive builds favor lower Attack IVs because the CP calculation gives Attack considerable weight; that is a reason to investigate, not a rule that every low-Attack Pokémon is good.

A collector may value a perfect appraisal, an unusual costume or a personal memory for entirely different reasons. Give those Pokémon a collection tag. Separating collection goals from battle goals makes it easier to decide which duplicate is genuinely spare and which one belongs in a long-term collection.

Know which actions change your options

Ordinary evolution and power-ups do not improve appraisal. They change the Pokémon’s form or current strength, so do not spend Candy expecting an extra appraisal star. Purification can improve a Shadow Pokémon’s appraisal but also changes its battle characteristics. Hyper Training is a separate feature; check its eligibility, item and task requirements rather than treating it as an ordinary power-up.

Before investing in a league candidate, preview its resulting CP and read any evolution requirements. Powering beyond a league cap is not a reversible adjustment. Before purifying, consider whether you want to retain that particular Shadow Pokémon. A higher-looking appraisal is not, on its own, a complete explanation of a better battle outcome.

A practical keep-or-transfer checklist

First favorite the Pokémon you know you want to protect. Then sort your remaining duplicates by species. Identify one or two useful battle candidates, any collection pieces, and anything you want to offer in a trade. Tag unfinished decisions instead of resolving them in a hurry while your storage warning is on screen.

Try applying this process to one family before your whole collection. Compare appraisal, current investment, moves and intended league; then write a short tag such as Raid project or Great League check. You will make fewer mistakes with a small, understandable system than with a complicated filter whose results you have not reviewed.

Sources & further reading

Game details can change. Check the linked official sources and the current in-game information. Reviewed: Oct 4, 2026.